Menu
Call
Get $75-$4,500 Avoya Cash CLAIM YOUR AVOYA CASH NOW!

Carnival Cruises - Carnival Magic Reviews

Carnival Cruises
Carnival Magic
All Star Ratings
Date (Most Recent)
*All reviews are by verified customers that have traveled by booking through a travel agent in the Avoya Network
“Food leaves a lot to be desired ”
2 Stars
Cruise Date: 02/08/2025
Destination: Caribbean
This is not a reflection of Avoya. travel. The food on carnival has just steadily gotten worse as time has passed. You don't notice it on the bigger ships but the smaller ships will no longer be on our sailing list.
Reviewed about 1 month ago by Diane
“Cruise on the Magic ”
4 Stars
Cruise Date: 02/08/2025
Destination: Caribbean
It was a good trip as far as being with wife, daughter and son in law. Aruba and Curacao never disappoint! As for the Magic, it wasn't so magical; disappointed in dining and overall cleanliness. Lots of people with colds on the ship, son in law got sick and was in room for 4 of 8 days, wife and daughter were getting sick on final day at sea, leaving me to drive 12 hours with 3 flu/covid passengers. Was definitely memorable but not in the way we were hoping for.
Reviewed about 1 month ago by Mark
“Carnival Magic , great ship and crew”
5 Stars
Cruise Date: 12/30/2023
Destination: Caribbean
The itinerary was perfect, beaches were , great, only disappointment was even though we requested small table we got a ten top. The table is so large we can t hear conversations of folks from other side of table. If we request small table, that’s what we should get wait staff terrific. Cabin steward, top notch
Reviewed about 1 year ago by Barry
“Carnival Magic”
2 Stars
Cruise Date: 07/16/2023
Destination: Caribbean
There were not enough activities on the days we were at sea, mainly trivia games. The 2 pools were too small for this size ship. Was disappointed that on the Elegant Nights that there were no tablecloths on the tables in the dining rooms. The reboarding in Bimini was horrible. The cruise ship had 2 doors open but it took us over 1 hr. waiting in the hot 90+ temperatures to get back on the ship Lines at the buffets were slow. The pizza station was understaffed. I waited 1 day for 15 min. with no movement and then left. Should have had more dancing on the Lido deck instead of showing movies
Reviewed over 1 year ago by Joanne
5 Stars
Cruise Date: 10/15/2022
Destination: Caribbean
Cruise director was great along with the entertainment.
Reviewed over 2 years ago by Larry
“Great entertainment. Wonderful shows. ”
3 Stars
Cruise Date: 10/15/2022
Destination: Caribbean
The air quality on ship is poor. Cigarette smoke permeates the entire 5th deck from the casino. Such a shame. Food was mostly good. Not outstanding. Cigarette smoke was awful. And we are not sensitive to it. It came up from deck 5 to our balcony on 6. People are allowed to smoke on the decks. Air flow is poor. Got Covid.
Reviewed over 2 years ago by James
“Great Birthday Celebration ”
5 Stars
Cruise Date: 10/15/2022
Destination: Caribbean
Everything was great. I missed having a birthday gift waiting for me in my cabin but it was a great time overall. Looking forward to receiving my check in the mail for the booking special.
Reviewed over 2 years ago by Sharon
“Food was excellent except specialty steak house ”
5 Stars
Cruise Date: 10/10/2022
Destination: Caribbean
Steak was ordered Med rare arrived at table well done. Instead of preparing a new steak they tried to work on the original steak. It still was well done. They didn’t charge us for the steak but the dinner was ruined for her and I .
Reviewed over 2 years ago by Donna
4 Stars
Cruise Date: 09/17/2022
Destination: USA/Canada
Reviewed over 2 years ago by Carmelita
“Carnival Magic 5 Night Bermuda out of NY”
5 Stars
Cruise Date: 08/31/2022
Destination: Caribbean
Everything was awesome. Embrkment and disbarkment each took about 15 minutes. I've never cared about who the cruise director was. Let me tell you, Ryan Rose is exceptional. He is magnetic. I would cruise a ship just because he's the CD. He knows how to get a crowd going. MDR great. The Marketplace, great. Cucina Del Capitano-great! Do the Italiam restaurant for lunch! It's included in your fare, no extra fee and it's a little slice of heaven. Bermuda-Bermuda Triangle Shipwreck Snorkel-amazing. Well worth every penny. Horseshoe Bay Beach transfer safe and efficient, but overpric
Reviewed over 2 years ago by Christine
“great weather”
4 Stars
Cruise Date: 05/21/2022
Destination: Caribbean
debarkation not good,very slow
Reviewed almost 3 years ago by Roger
“it was ok”
4 Stars
Cruise Date: 03/20/2022
Destination: Caribbean
Reviewed almost 3 years ago by William
4 Stars
Cruise Date: 03/20/2022
Destination: Caribbean
It was nice,didn’t like the lines for the buffet and shower dripped
Reviewed almost 3 years ago by Christine
5 Stars
Cruise Date: 03/12/2022
Destination: Caribbean
Reviewed almost 3 years ago by Kimberley
“Nice cruise.”
4 Stars
Cruise Date: 03/12/2022
Destination: Caribbean
Reviewed almost 3 years ago by Michael
“the magic cruise”
4 Stars
Cruise Date: 12/04/2021
Destination: Caribbean
smooth sailing
Reviewed over 3 years ago by Roger
3 Stars
Cruise Date: 11/20/2021
Destination: Caribbean
Reviewed over 3 years ago by Paul
“BALCONY ARE RUSTED, TO SHORT OF STAY IN PORT AND TO LONG IN NAVIGATIONS, BESIDES ; THE MOST EXPENSIVE INTERNET PACKAGE OF ANY CRUISE (32) I HAVE TAKEN.”
3 Stars
Cruise Date: 11/20/2021
Destination: Caribbean
Reviewed over 3 years ago by Santo
3 Stars
Cruise Date: 11/20/2021
Destination: Caribbean
Reviewed over 3 years ago by Janet
“Subpar”
2 Stars
Cruise Date: 10/02/2021
Destination: Caribbean
While the ship was clean and the staff friendly, the food was bland and the shows were mediocre. Half Moon Cay was beautiful. Day at Sea was dull. Nassau was mostly closed down. Bimini was beautiful and the only place we paid for an excursion. We did snorkeling at the shipwreck, would highly recommend it.
Reviewed over 3 years ago by Alberto
“Worst cruise ever!”
1 Star
Cruise Date: 01/04/2020
Destination: Caribbean
8 nights. 2 shore excursions cancelled, 1 port cancelled due to weather, mediocre food, lousy shows.
Reviewed about 5 years ago by Karen
3 Stars
Cruise Date: 12/07/2019
Destination: Caribbean
Reviewed about 5 years ago by Victoria
3 Stars
Cruise Date: 12/21/2019
Destination: Caribbean
Had a great time with my family ambit my mom and aunt had a horrible time trying to move around the ship being they are both blind. We hope our next experience is much better. We wish you all a happy new year
Reviewed about 5 years ago by Donovan
“Christmas 2019 Cruise ”
3 Stars
Cruise Date: 12/21/2019
Destination: Caribbean
As a family we had a good time however the staff was not accommodating to the disabled. However after meeting with guest services they improved. We hope moving forward that carnival magic will make ever Effect to accommodate the visually impaired and others with disability’s . We wish the crew well and a happy new year.
Reviewed about 5 years ago by Niaijah
“Fun cruise food was ok”
4 Stars
Cruise Date: 11/23/2019
Destination: Caribbean
Fun cruise. Lots to do, ports were great! The singers were not good and the serenity deck should not be near the kids slid. Not very quiet there.
Reviewed over 5 years ago by Janet
Don't Miss the Latest Deals!
Talk to a Vacation Planner
Avoya Travel Logo Mark
Why Choose Avoya?
U.S. / Canada: 1-888-877-7042
UK: 0-800-098-8475
Australia: 1-800-651-320
International: 001-760-305-5070
Avoya Travel. Beyond The Web.®
CST: 2085569-40
Fla. Seller of Travel Ref. No. ST36781
© Avoya Travel®. All Rights Reserved.
Avoya Travel Logo